Mind control through the magician’s force
Back in 1893, Dessoir (Dessoir, 1893) noted that magicians have powerful ways of influencing people’s decisions, and that these processes provide a useful tool to study our sense of free will and agency: forcing techniques (Kuhn, Amlani, & Rensink, 2008). More than one hundred years later, current psychological research highlights that our subjective experience of free will may be an illusion and that instead many of our choices are influenced by a number of different unconscious factors.
Free will is at the center of human behavior, thoughts, morality, and responsibility. The idea that we are in control, and the causal agents of what we think and do, lies at the heart of our conception of ourselves. Understanding the psychological factors that lead to erroneous sense of agency is therefore of great importance, and it has wide ranging implications for forensic assessments of criminal responsibility, criminal punishments and related public policies derived from this.
The magician’s force illustrates a powerful error in the sense of free will, and this illusion has important theoretical (e.g. the understanding of the nature of human beings and how we make our decisions), clinical (e.g. thought insertion in schizophrenia, alien hand syndrome) and applied implications (e.g. marketing, political propaganda, well-being). Studying the processes involved in this illusion provides, among other things, valuable insights into decision-making processes, new ways to present choices so as to encourage better decisions related to health and well-being, as well as a better understanding of cognitive mechanisms that lead people to experience a distorted sense of agency.
Alice Pailhes is exploring the nature of forcing and aims to identify and investigate ways in which magicians covertly influence our decision making through forcing. The project aims to 1) identify effective forcing techniques, 2) identify the psychological mechanisms that underpin these forces, and 3) investigate psychological factors that contribute to people’s illusory sense of free will.
In collaboration with Yuxuan Lan we have been exploring a psychological force that we coined the Implicit Choice Restriction force, in which magicians use subtle implicit suggestions to restrict the items that come to your mind.
Hugo Cafferatti is currently also exploring a force in which the to be forced item is placed in a strategic position, and subtle forms of suggestion are used to influence a persons’ choice.
Dessoir, M. (1893). The psychology of legerdemain. The Open Court, 12, 3599–3606.
Kuhn, G., Amlani, A. A., & Rensink, R. A. (2008). Towards a science of magic. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 12(9), 349-354. doi: 10.1016/j.tics.2008.05.008